Wednesday, 5 October 2011

COB: the contemporary press (part 2)

Clive Palmer, Mick Bennett, John Bidwell and Genevieve Val Baker

Following the release of Spirit Of Love in November 1971, COB played a few gigs, but largely focused on getting a new set of songs together back in Cornwall. They added Genevieve Val Baker (whose sister Demelza had played with Palmer and Bidwell in the Temple Creatures) on drums and percussion, and by July 1971 they had a single ready for release. Produced by Ralph McTell, Blue Morning / Bones appeared on Polydor, following the dissolution of their manager Jo Lustig's arrangement with CBS. Lustig had apparently instructed them to come up with something deliberately commercial, and the result is a good-natured pop record that sounds little like the rest of their work. The A-side verges on reggae, and the flip is almost a novelty song. It's an anomaly in their catalogue, and seems to have baffled Rosalind Russell when she interviewed them for Disc on July 29th 1972:

The same issue carried a review of the 45, which repeated Russell's remarks:

Sales were minuscule, but it was also issued in Germany, with a picture sleeve:

In late July, they went back into the studio in London to record their second and final album, with some striking assistance by Danny Thompson on double bass. Thankfully, they'd got the lightweight pop out of their system, and created one of the great masterpieces of modern English music, Moyshe McStiff & The Tartan Lancers Of The Sacred Heart. Produced by McTell - whose skill in managing their sound deserves the highest praise - it was completed by August 6th, which is the date scribbled on the mastertape. Soon afterwards they performed at the Cambridge Folk Festival. Here's their entry in the programme:

With the release of Moyshe approaching, they gave a fascinating interview to Melody Maker on September 14th:

On Saturday 20th they played a gig with Gillian McPherson and Bridget St. John at the Basildon Arts Centre. Here's their page from the programme:

The album appeared as part of Polydor's short-lived 'Folk Mill' imprint in early October, and was trailed in a couple of papers:

Here's a promo photo Polydor issued at the time. Though Genny Val Baker is prominent in it, she only appears in an intermittent supporting role on the record, which was evidently made as a trio, and not the quartet Palmer had spoken of earlier in the year:

The striking artwork was by Paul Whitehead (who also designed covers for High Tide, Andrew Leigh, Genesis and others), and it came with another gatefold sleeve containing all the lyrics:

Incidentally, I spoke to Whitehead about the album, and this is what he said: "Boy! That's a blast from the past. If I remember correctly, that was an airbrushed piece involving a dragon and the band slaying it - right? I did a lot of covers in the 70s and they all seem to blur into each other in terms of the creative process involved. I usually insisted on hearing the music as it was written, or at least reading the lyrics. I remember meeting with one of the band. We talked about the concept and I showed him some pictures from a Victorian illustrated book about King Arthur as a possible way to go. Once everyone (band and record company) agreed that was a good direction, I just got to work. I don't have a copy of the cover and I imagine the original piece is in the possession of the record company - if they still exist."

The two reviews I have found were broadly complimentary, though Jerry Gilbert in Sounds mystifyingly criticised the trio's brilliant vocals, which apparently 'should have been stronger':

Sounds, October 14th 1972
Melody Maker, October 14th 1972
On October 14th another interesting article appeared in Melody Maker, written by Eric Winter:

As the article explains, to promote the album they went on a prestigious tour with Pentangle and Wizz Jones, which had been advertised in Melody Maker on September 23rd:

Here's the 'souvenir brochure' cover (billing them as 'Clive Palmer's COB') and their section:

The tour was well-received, if a little shambolic, reflecting the turbulence in Pentangle at the time (they split as soon as the tour ended). COB's performance in Croydon on November 5th got a lukewarm notice in the local paper on the 10th:

By then, however, long-term hardship had exacerbated their personal differences and the initial magic had gone. They persevered with a weekly residency in one of London's leading folk venues, the Half Moon in Putney, but split for good in March 1973, without making any further recordings. Their full story can be read in the notes to the Sunbeam reissue of Moyshe McStiff, and I recommend Grahame Hood's biography of Clive Palmer, Empty Pocket Blues, but I'll end here with a statement Ralph McTell made to me when I was working on the reissue: "COB was about three guys living in the middle of nowhere who somehow came up with this magical music. I feel we got the absolute best out of each other, and couldn't have improved the records in any way. In my opinion they stand head and shoulders above most of what passed for music at the time, and I'm very, very proud of what we achieved together."


  1. The bootleg live album version of "Blue Morning" suggests that it would have been much improved if the reggae parts had been removed...

  2. Thanks for posting all these cuttings, I enjoyed reading them. I remember buying "Blue Morning" for 20p at the Berwick Street market stall that eventually became the Cheapo record shop, very soon after its release. The music was good, but the sound (i.e. the pressing) of the 45 always struck me as being rather poor.
    Is there any chance of further unreleased or live COB material coming out on Sunbeam? I seem to remember mention of the possibility of a live album in Grahame Hood's book.
    I was lucky enough to go to a couple of COB gigs, the first being at Cambridge Town Hall (at around the time of the first album, supporting Tom Paxton, I think). On that occasion they played a number of songs from Spirit of Love but I also remember a tune with the repeated chorus "I've got fish heads in my bed again" (!). The second gig was on May 12th 1972, at Essex University (supporting Natural Acoustic Band and Country Joe MacDonald). I have my own rather basic cassette recording of it and, apart from a mixture of songs from the two albums, there are three unreleased numbers: a rather good song sung by Clive (with the repeated line "Open Your Eyes"), the instrumental "Boom Boom" (referred to in the Croydon review) and a rather Scottish sounding number, which I seem to recall was about Charles Stuart ( I only have some of the between song announcements on tape). As far as the second gig is concerned, I think it would be fair to say that the unreleased songs are not quite up to the outstanding quality of those on Moyshe Mc Stiff but, if they exist on good quality recordings, I'm sure they would be of interest to COB/Clive fans. Bearing in mind that there were at least four unreleased numbers performed at just these two gigs, there may well have been other songs that were performed live but never made it onto record.

  3. Great to hear from an original fan! That Essex tape you have sounds like a treasure. Any chance I can get a copy? I went through a lot of unreleased material (none of it recorded in the studio) to choose the bonus tracks for the reissue of Moyshe on Sunbeam. There were several versions of certain songs, but I don't recall the ones you mention. I fear that the live tape that has already been circulating is a little too ragged for proper circulation.

  4. Hi Richard- hope this is of interest, I've been trying to get as many COB live dates as I can.

    I’ve been trying to work out the exact dates of the last few months of the original C.O.B. using copies of the Melody Maker from 1973. I am missing a few copies but here is what I have found out so far. John Bidwell told me that the band had no bookings arranged after the Pentangle tour in late 1972. I have all the MMs up to w/e 10/02 (which is a Saturday, though the MM came out on Thursdays) and the first mention is;
    Friday 26/01/73 Half Moon, Lower Richmond Road, Putney. “Clive Palmer C.O.B”
    Advert in MM for bookings giving 01 366 6904
    I’m missing w/e 17/02 and 24/02 and suspect the latter may also show a Half Moon gig. Clive recalls the Half Moon gigs as a residency but it seems more likely to have been just a regular (4 weekly?) gig. John Bidwell and Mick Bennett both now think this was the case.
    Sunday 18/03/73 Candlelight, Nag’s Head, 205 York Road, Battersea “C.O.B. Clive Palmer with Jugular Vein”
    Monday 19/03/73 The Derby Arms, 565 Upper Richmond Road West “Clive Palmer’s C.O.B.”
    Friday 30/03/73 Half Moon Putney “Balham Banjo Band with Wizz Jones & Sandy, Don Coging, Clive Palmer, Jim (sic) Bidwell, Henry the Jug etc al. Pageant.”
    I have asked both John and Mick about the following gigs, they don’t remember them, so presumably they were done with the new line-up of C.O.B. featuring Henry Bartlett and Chris Newman. It is interesting to see that C.O.B. were starting to get a fair bit of work, and these gigs are only the ones shown in the MM Folk Forum, which was very London-centric. I don’t see Clive turning down paid gigs at a time when it was pretty much his only source of income, and given that the new trio played mainly jug band material, it wouldn’t have taken him long to put two half- hour folk club sets together. An hour probably!
    Thursday 12/04/73 White Bear, Hounslow “The Incredible C.O.B. + Chalice”
    Friday 13/04/73 Half Moon Putney “C.O.B. + Pageant”
    Tuesday 23/04/73 Down River 1, King William IV, Leyton High Road “C.O.B.”
    In a later announcement C.O.B were due to play a charity gig organised by the same club in June.
    Thursday 03/05/73 Shakespeare’s Head, Carnaby Street W1 “C.O.B. with Beckett”
    Friday 04/05/73 Folk at the Oak, Dulwich SE21 (South Circular) 30p. “C.O.B.”
    Melody Maker Folk Forum 19/05/73 “John Bidwell and Mick Bennett have left C.O.B. to pursue solo careers. Clive Bunker (!) is now gigging with Henry Bartlett and Chris Newman”
    Sunday 27/05 Cabbage Patch, London Road, Twickenham “C.O.B.”
    Saturday 09/06/1973 Hull Folk Festival “C.O.B.”
    C.O.B played at the Norwich Folk Festival 15,16,17th June. C.O.B were due to play on both the Saturday and the Sunday. Mick Bennet’s new band Scarlet Runner (Mick returned to Cornwall the day after the Half Moon incident) featuring Sandy Spencer on cello and Tim Wellard and Thom Podgeretsky on guitars also played.
    Melody Maker Student Statement 30/06/73 “Clive Bunker (again!) has now joined forces with Henry Bartlett and Chris Newman. The trio are available for bookings through Bill Knox…(manager of the Half Moon)”
    Melody Maker Student Statement 07/07/73 “Contrary to last week’s news story it is Clive Palmer who’s joining forces with Henry Bartlett and Chris Newman, the latter two recently having replaced Mick Bennet and John Bidwell in C.O.B. Enquiries should be made to… (Gives Clive’s father’s address and phone number) “
    Did C.O.B. ever trouble the pages of the MM again?